{"schemaVersion":"1.0.0","evaluationReviewId":"qeravio-public-evaluation-review:1.0.0","readAt":"2026-08-22T04:33:24.585Z","servingVersion":{"id":"4f2cf40b-a6fd-4f50-b8e3-64efa4108c2c","uploadedAt":"2026-08-22T01:57:02.887779Z"},"reviewOwner":{"protocolAuthor":"qeravio_evaluation_protocol_builder_ai","independentChecker":"seal_ai_metric_checker","peopleEmployedForReview":0,"separationRequired":true},"corpus":{"version":"1.0.0","protocolCount":5,"criterionCount":20,"evidenceRequirementCount":15,"records":[{"protocolId":"chatgpt:2026-08-13","toolId":"chatgpt","designedAt":"2026-08-13","retestBy":"2026-09-13","criterionCount":4,"evidenceRequirementCount":3,"weightTotal":100,"protocolState":"ready","resultState":"not_run","recommendationState":"withheld_no_verified_result","boundary":{"en":"The protocol is ready. Qeravio has not run this tool test or published a score or recommendation.","he":"הפרוטוקול מוכן. קראוויאו לא הריצה את בדיקת הכלי ולא פרסמה ציון או המלצה."}},{"protocolId":"claude:2026-08-13","toolId":"claude","designedAt":"2026-08-13","retestBy":"2026-09-13","criterionCount":4,"evidenceRequirementCount":3,"weightTotal":100,"protocolState":"ready","resultState":"not_run","recommendationState":"withheld_no_verified_result","boundary":{"en":"The protocol is ready. Qeravio has not run this tool test or published a score or recommendation.","he":"הפרוטוקול מוכן. קראוויאו לא הריצה את בדיקת הכלי ולא פרסמה ציון או המלצה."}},{"protocolId":"gemini:2026-08-13","toolId":"gemini","designedAt":"2026-08-13","retestBy":"2026-09-13","criterionCount":4,"evidenceRequirementCount":3,"weightTotal":100,"protocolState":"ready","resultState":"not_run","recommendationState":"withheld_no_verified_result","boundary":{"en":"The protocol is ready. Qeravio has not run this tool test or published a score or recommendation.","he":"הפרוטוקול מוכן. קראוויאו לא הריצה את בדיקת הכלי ולא פרסמה ציון או המלצה."}},{"protocolId":"descript:2026-08-13","toolId":"descript","designedAt":"2026-08-13","retestBy":"2026-09-13","criterionCount":4,"evidenceRequirementCount":3,"weightTotal":100,"protocolState":"ready","resultState":"not_run","recommendationState":"withheld_no_verified_result","boundary":{"en":"The protocol is ready. Qeravio has not run this tool test or published a score or recommendation.","he":"הפרוטוקול מוכן. קראוויאו לא הריצה את בדיקת הכלי ולא פרסמה ציון או המלצה."}},{"protocolId":"notion:2026-08-13","toolId":"notion","designedAt":"2026-08-13","retestBy":"2026-09-13","criterionCount":4,"evidenceRequirementCount":3,"weightTotal":100,"protocolState":"ready","resultState":"not_run","recommendationState":"withheld_no_verified_result","boundary":{"en":"The protocol is ready. Qeravio has not run this tool test or published a score or recommendation.","he":"הפרוטוקול מוכן. קראוויאו לא הריצה את בדיקת הכלי ולא פרסמה ציון או המלצה."}}]},"publicationGates":[{"id":"verified_state_required","outcome":"publication_blocked_on_failure","reviewStatus":"passed_by_code_and_test","description":{"en":"Draft, prepared, running, submitted, rejected and expired records cannot publish a score.","he":"רשומה בטיוטה, בהכנה, בהרצה, בהגשה, בדחייה או בתוקף שפג אינה יכולה לפרסם ציון."}},{"id":"independent_checker_required","outcome":"publication_blocked_on_failure","reviewStatus":"passed_by_code_and_test","description":{"en":"The checker must exist and must not be the test operator.","he":"הבודק חייב להיות מוגדר ואסור שיהיה מפעיל הבדיקה."}},{"id":"protocol_version_binding","outcome":"publication_blocked_on_failure","reviewStatus":"passed_by_code_and_test","description":{"en":"A result must match the exact current protocol design date.","he":"תוצאה חייבת להתאים בדיוק לתאריך התכנון של הפרוטוקול הנוכחי."}},{"id":"valid_test_time","outcome":"publication_blocked_on_failure","reviewStatus":"passed_by_code_and_test","description":{"en":"The test time must be valid, after protocol design and not in the future.","he":"מועד הבדיקה חייב להיות תקין, לאחר תכנון הפרוטוקול ולא בעתיד."}},{"id":"retest_deadline","outcome":"publication_blocked_on_failure","reviewStatus":"passed_by_code_and_test","description":{"en":"An expired protocol or result cannot publish a current score.","he":"פרוטוקול או תוצאה שפג תוקפם אינם יכולים לפרסם ציון עדכני."}},{"id":"complete_unique_evidence","outcome":"publication_blocked_on_failure","reviewStatus":"passed_by_code_and_test","description":{"en":"Every required evidence reference must be present, non-empty and unique.","he":"כל הפניה נדרשת לראיה חייבת להיות קיימת, מלאה וייחודית."}},{"id":"criterion_shape","outcome":"publication_blocked_on_failure","reviewStatus":"passed_by_code_and_test","description":{"en":"Every criterion must have one finite score in the permitted range.","he":"לכל מדד חייב להיות ציון סופי אחד בטווח המותר."}},{"id":"complete_cost","outcome":"publication_blocked_on_failure","reviewStatus":"passed_by_code_and_test","description":{"en":"Missing, invalid or negative complete cost blocks publication.","he":"עלות מלאה חסרה, לא תקינה או שלילית חוסמת פרסום."}},{"id":"correction_time","outcome":"publication_blocked_on_failure","reviewStatus":"passed_by_code_and_test","description":{"en":"Missing, invalid or negative correction time blocks publication.","he":"זמן תיקון חסר, לא תקין או שלילי חוסם פרסום."}},{"id":"known_limitations","outcome":"publication_blocked_on_failure","reviewStatus":"passed_by_code_and_test","description":{"en":"At least one meaningful limitation must accompany the result.","he":"לפחות מגבלה מהותית אחת חייבת להופיע לצד התוצאה."}},{"id":"commercial_influence_review","outcome":"publication_blocked_on_failure","reviewStatus":"passed_by_code_and_test","description":{"en":"A score stays hidden until commercial influence is reviewed and any relationship is disclosed.","he":"ציון נשאר מוסתר עד לבדיקת השפעה מסחרית ולגילוי כל קשר רלוונטי."}},{"id":"runtime_evidence_available","outcome":"publication_blocked_on_failure","reviewStatus":"passed_by_code_and_test","description":{"en":"Missing database evidence or a changed Worker version produces a pending state, never inherited approval.","he":"ראיית מסד נתונים חסרה או שינוי בגרסת המערכת יוצרים מצב ממתין, לעולם לא אישור שעובר בירושה."}}],"correctedFindings":[{"id":"result_not_bound_to_protocol_version","severity":"P1","correction":{"en":"Every publishable result now has to match the current protocol design date.","he":"כל תוצאה שניתנת לפרסום חייבת כעת להתאים לתאריך התכנון של הפרוטוקול הנוכחי."}},{"id":"commercial_influence_not_a_hard_gate","severity":"P1","correction":{"en":"Commercial influence review and disclosure are now hard publication gates.","he":"בדיקת השפעה מסחרית וגילוי נאות הם כעת שערי פרסום מחייבים."}},{"id":"result_time_not_validated","severity":"P2","correction":{"en":"Invalid, future, pre-protocol and expired test times now fail closed.","he":"מועדי בדיקה לא תקינים, עתידיים, מוקדמים מהפרוטוקול או שפג תוקפם נכשלים כעת באופן סגור."}},{"id":"duplicate_or_blank_evidence","severity":"P2","correction":{"en":"Blank or duplicate evidence references can no longer satisfy the evidence count.","he":"הפניות ריקות או כפולות אינן יכולות עוד להשלים את מכסת הראיות."}},{"id":"blank_limitations","severity":"P2","correction":{"en":"Blank limitations can no longer unlock a result.","he":"מגבלות ריקות אינן יכולות עוד לפתוח תוצאה לפרסום."}},{"id":"release_review_not_version_bound","severity":"P2","correction":{"en":"The public governance review now belongs to one exact Worker and fails closed after a version change.","he":"בדיקת הממשל הציבורית שייכת כעת לגרסת מערכת מדויקת אחת ונכשלת באופן סגור לאחר שינוי גרסה."}}],"openGates":["Run every protocol against the named real tool version and preserve the original input, settings, output, time and cost evidence.","Assign an independent checker for every individual result and preserve the complete append-only review history.","Publish source-linked evidence passports for every score without exposing private or licensed test material.","Review and disclose every sponsorship, affiliate relationship, free access, vendor contact or other commercial influence before publishing a result.","Repeat results across representative tasks, versions and time before making a comparative or general recommendation.","Complete external security, privacy, accessibility, legal and production-fit checks where a recommendation would imply those properties."],"claimBoundary":{"realToolRunsCompleted":false,"toolScoresPublished":false,"winnerPublished":false,"productRecommendationPublished":false,"wholeCatalogReviewed":false,"externalBenchmarkCompleted":false,"productionFitnessApproved":false,"securityOrPrivacyCertified":false,"commercialInfluenceCleared":false,"repeatUseValueProven":false},"state":"release_verification_pending","reason":"serving_version_changed","releaseEvidence":{"workerVersionId":"56bbaf52-e861-4c6d-870e-87c2369a2b78","verificationCompletedAt":"2026-08-20T18:57:14.474Z","reviewMethod":"independent_ai_metric_governance_review","reviewCorpusVersion":"1.0.0","protocolCount":5,"criterionCount":20,"evidenceRequirementCount":15,"negativeGateCount":12,"correctedFindingCount":6,"publishedScoreCount":0,"publishedRecommendationCount":0,"openP0Count":0,"openP1Count":0,"openP2Count":0,"reviewerSeparatedFromAuthor":true,"independentReviewStatus":"passed_after_fail_closed_corrections","realToolRunStatus":"not_run","commercialInfluenceStatus":"not_reviewed_results_withheld","evidenceId":"qeravio-qtop189-public-evaluation-review-release-20260820T185710Z"}}